New Artist Spotlight
  • Home
  • Interviews & Reviews
  • Podcast
  • Top20
  • Radio
  • Merch
  • Team
  • Playlists
  • AMA
  • Pre-Saves
  • More
    • NAS Gig Calendar
    • Info
    • About Us
    • Contact

𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Melanie Klein – Frank Joshua

Written by

Charles Connolly

in

Connolly’s Corner

Welcome all to 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿, a series of weekly reviews by Charles Connolly – an artist in his own right. Here, Charles delves into the greatest brand new singles brought to you by the best unsigned artists on our electrifying and eclectic set of 𝙉𝙚𝙬 𝘼𝙧𝙩𝙞𝙨𝙩 𝙎𝙥𝙤𝙩𝙡𝙞𝙜𝙝𝙩 playlists.


𝙈𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙞𝙚 𝙆𝙡𝙚𝙞𝙣 – 𝙁𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙠 𝙅𝙤𝙨𝙝𝙪𝙖


Charles analyses the situation…


There has been an increasing rarity of something in my reviews lately. Please don’t all shout at once: “Rap! Death Metal! Brevity!”… I know, I know. I’m more talking about something that used to be quite common in these parts. But has only come up maybe three or four times this year. We’ve had plenty of the rock, the indie, the alternative, the folk, the classical, the soul, the pop, the prog, and even the reggae. So, what am I talking about? What is missing? It’s something that is actually relatively common. But rarely of a high standard, because it’s bloody hard to do well; notoriously so. It has to sound polished. It has to sound classic. It usually has to sound professional (but there can be a certain charm when it’s not). It can be peaceful, but usually it’s sad; and it can be heart-wrenching. I’m talking about ballads.


Ballads are kind of everywhere. The problem is, most of them are rather dull, and lacking in a higher fidelity. That’s in the independent music scene. In the mainstream, they barely exist at the moment. They’re VERY out of fashion. In fact, I’m not really sure what IS in fashion. This could be a sign of my age being somewhat average, meaning I’m out of touch… Or it could be because the mainstream music scene is kind of lost. I think it might be the latter. Ballads tend to make you think and feel. Right now, it seems like the world (powers that be) doesn’t (don’t) want you to think or feel. There, danger lies. Which could explain the plasticity of mainstream songs these days. It is fodder to keep us at bay. A pacifier of sorts… You’d think that a rebellion-style song would be more effective in rousing the troops, and therefore something of which the mainstream would vehemently want to steer clear. The thing is, that’s the “troops”. That’s a big load of people “against the system”. Seems like the worst for “them”, right? Well, not necessarily. This way you’d have sheep culture. And sheep are easy to herd. They all think the same and feel the same, so once you’ve worked out a way of steering one, you’ve steered them all. Ballads though… Oof! Now you’ve hit something personal. Each and every individual will think and feel differently upon hearing a ballad. It’s an individual thing. It’s private. People don’t listen to ballads in the club with another hundred people… Oh what a hilarious thought: pilled up to the rafters, drunk as a skunk, all dancing away to Barry Manilow and Barbra Streisand. Pahaha!! Sorry, I don’t often chuckle in my Corner. I just couldn’t resist the image. Anyway! People tend to listen to ballads on their lonesome. And each listener will start to think and feel and remember, and often get a little teary-eyed.


But then I thought about the psychology of it all. Why do we like ballads? They’re slow, and they’re usually sad. Why should we want to listen to anything sad?? It’s a very good point! Sadness is a negative feeling. If you’re sad, you want to be happy again. If you’re happy, you want to stay happy. So what’s the point of it? I think it’s because we like to feel. It doesn’t so much need to be a happy feeling, but a feeling. Happiness is wonderful, but rarely as deep a feeling as sadness. You know when we say “I couldn’t be happier”… Do we really mean that? There is always “happier”. But sadness…? When you think you’re at your lowest (you’re probably not), you feel at your absolute lowest. Proof that sadness is the winner of all feelings. It’s a bludgeoning compared to a lollipop. That’s why ‘Tears in Heaven’ hits harder than the (technically) harder-hitting ‘Watermelon Sugar’. Also because ‘Tears in Heaven’ is a far superior song. So yeah, I think THAT’S why we are drawn to ballads. But I think it’s more about relating. “Uptown Funk gonh’ give it t’ ya”… But is it REALLY gonh’ give it t’ ya? It’ll make ya move, sure, but is it going to move your heart? Potentially, to the point of ambulance bells, should you move a little too much… But that’s not what I mean, and you know it. We can’t really relate to lyrics like “Take a sip, sign the check. Julio, get the stretch! Ride to Harlem, Hollywood, Jackson, Mississippi”… Hella cool though it is, it’s not really the life we know. But the loss of loved ones, and the break-up of a once perfect relationship…? These are things that we ALL go through. And THEY’RE the things that stick with us. That’s my pseudo psycho analyses out of the way, anyway. More just my own theoretical musings and ponderings, but perhaps interesting nevertheless. There might be a little more psycho analysis to come, though…


Let’s talk about one specific ballad that has just sprung from the womb. Well… This particular artist could never be a mother. More on mothers later. For now, we’ll stick with the one and only Frank Joshua, with his brand new release, Melanie Klein. And yes, my instant thought was your instant thought: “I want some peanuts”. No, it was “Who’s Melanie Klein?”. I’m right, right? Right. I thought as much. Melanie Klein was an unhappy mother. Or should I say, an unhappy wife. She lived a while ago, with the kindest face, the warmest heart and the most ravenous brain. She was obsessed with human behaviour, and a staunch supporter of Sigmund Freud, championing many of his beliefs (and arguing over others), but wishing to go further in terms of research. Although Freud was sure that any anomalies in human behaviour were due to childhood trauma, he was adamant that it was impossible to analyse the mind of a child. Melanie Klein realised otherwise. She would do this by giving children toys, and observing their behaviour as they play. I won’t go into too much detail, but her work concluded something along the lines of there being a good breast and a bad breast. Yes, she went from toys to boobs. It seems like the logical progression to me. Basically, she was a brilliant woman, stuck in a man’s world. She eventually left her horrid husband and continued her research as a psycho-analyst for the rest of her life.


So, has London’s Frank Joshua written a song about her life, or about her work…? Not really, no. One could perhaps argue that it is more a story about her unhappy marriage… Perhaps how separation can be not only hard on the two involved, but how it can weigh heavily on the children as well… However, I suspect it to be not even this. Let’s call it beautiful artistic licence. As always, I could be entirely wrong. The good news is, there won’t be any more psycho-chat from me, and we can get into the world of Frank. However, we will finish our behavioural studies with a brief look at Freud’s most famous notion: we men are all in love with our mothers… Hmmm… So Frank’s in love with his mother…? Let’s turn that on its head. All mothers are in love with Frank Joshua. Now, this isn’t a notion, but in fact, a fact. And with a voice so creamy, who can blame them!! Seriously though, mothers all over the world are swooning and falling for Frank Joshua. It’s an epidemic verging on a pandemic. But here’s something of which all you mothers will be mighty jealous… I’ve met him, in person. I was surprised and not surprised. I expected a great bouffant of blondy-browny hair. This was not the case. But rather amazingly, I got the face kinda spot on. That’s right, ladies, his face suits his voice! He is indeed, as they say, a catch. A charming dish, if you will. The thing is, this column is not for Women’s Weekly, it’s for the New Artist Spotlight, so let’s talk about the music!


The music starts not with Frank, but with a man called Tony White; Frank’s longterm producer. An inattentive ear might hear piano and little more. I urge you to listen to the first ten seconds properly. There is indeed piano, but also cello, soft synths and atmospheric sound effects. Tony is and has always been a master of sound design, going far further than most. He just KNOWS. But already it’s time for THOSE vocals: that’s Frank’s shtick. Simmer down, ladies, for God’s sake; you’re married! Yes, I know he’s talking about you. He’s observant and truly empathetic; he feels your pain. He’s strong but sensitive: yes, your dream man. But I must again stress that this writing is supposed to be about music…! God though, WHAT a voice. The clarity, depth and focus is pretty much unrivalled. This chorus is enough to bring a man to tears: “I don’t know where you’ve been. I don’t know where you go. But if you try to love again, then I will know”. The bold strength in this full voice of Frank’s is astounding. It’s rare, and these days it’s basically unheard of. But before you’ve barely had time to wipe your eyes, in comes the most magical 10-second harmonica interlude. By the second chorus, the strings are stirring enough to surround this voice with a close love, like a gentle pair of hands cupping a live butterfly before setting it free. And I do promise you, this chorus and its stunning melodies will be in your head for a long time to come. But it is the final 23 seconds that really show off the passion and expertise in Frank’s voice. The restraint, the understated power; it’s as if we can watch him sing with one hand clenched for feeling, and two eyes clenched for concentration. He really is a brave man holding back the tears. THIS is an exquisite production.


Gotta go! My mother’s calling. Ach. I meant girlfriend. Slip of the tongue.


Listen to 𝙈𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙞𝙚 𝙆𝙡𝙚𝙞𝙣 on the 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 Spotify playlist HERE!

Listen to 𝙈𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙞𝙚 𝙆𝙡𝙚𝙞𝙣 on the 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 Apple Music playlist HERE!

Listen to 𝙈𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙞𝙚 𝙆𝙡𝙚𝙞𝙣 on YouTube HERE!


Follow 𝙁𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙠 𝙅𝙤𝙨𝙝𝙪𝙖 on Instagram HERE!

Follow 𝙁𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙠 𝙅𝙤𝙨𝙝𝙪𝙖 on TwiX HERE!


Please share this post and let me know your thoughts in the comments below

#review #song #songreview #MelanieKlein #FrankJoshua #London #ballad #piano #crooning #psychoanalysis #breakup #sadness #CharlesConnolly #ConnollysCorner #CC #NAS #NewArtistSpotlight #IWantMyNAS #StopPayola

←𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Manhã Dourada – João Aranha
𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Molly Bloom’s Monologue – Kele Fleming→

Comments

51 responses to “𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Melanie Klein – Frank Joshua”

  1. Kele Fleming Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Kele Fleming

    Love your talk on ballads. Great review and song, thank you!

    Reply
  2. Elizabeth Cook-Long Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Elizabeth Cook-Long

    All mothers love Frank Joshua! What a fun read & and inciteful critique of Melanie Klein (the ballad & the woman 😉.)

    Reply
  3. Roberta Plant Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Roberta Plant

    Now that you said that Frank’s face suits his voice…I’m so curious to meet him!! And oh, the harmonica intelude is really really powerful! I Totally agree.

    Reply
  4. Terry Gilbey Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Terry Gilbey

    I totally agree with you Charles about sadness being a much deeper feeling than happiness. I think the same applies to negative feelings such as anger, jealousy etc. I’ve often found it hardest to write lyrics during periods of happy stability, although in the scheme of things I wouldn’t swap those times for the sake of having something deeper to write about. The production and vocals on this track are immense and draw you into something very intimate. Every detail is there to appreciate.

    Reply
  5. Billy Castillo Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Billy Castillo

    Dude the production on this is top notch! And yeah , Frank is an amazing singer… I might have two weeks in a row where the CC review turns out to be my pick of the week…it’s between this and one other now

    Reply
  6. Tim Consley Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Tim Consley

    Frank’s vocals sound stellar, as always. Surprisingly, the harmonica solo just seems to flutter into the song. Such great instrumentation and vocals. Great song, Frank, and another great review, Charles!

    Reply
  7. Faded Element Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Faded Element

    Frank Joshua’s voice sounds so effortless! Especially on Melanie Klein. Love the harmonica btw 👏 Emotion for days on this one! Clean production and has the proper space for all parts to shine! Congrats on such a beautiful, brilliant tune Frank! Mr. CC, u sure know how to pick a song to review 👏

    Reply
  8. bathroomofthefuture Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    bathroomofthefuture

    So should we NOT expect you to review the new Gatecreeper, or

    Reply
  9. Wandile Keefelakae Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Wandile Keefelakae

    Melanie Klein- What a peculiar title for a song. Really an awesome style though. A song about the unhappy is a tearful one. We can learn to make the day brighter with this banger 🎶 🎶 ✨ ✨

    Reply
  10. Krauw Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Krauw

    rank Joshua’s ‘Melanie Klein’ is a stunning ballad that captures the essence of deep emotion and exquisite production. A true masterpiece!

    Reply
  11. William Lovitt Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    William Lovitt

    Charles start us off with some great thoughts about ballads and leads us to an excellent review of Frank Joshua’s latest masterpiece. Frank packs loads of passion, talent and vocal excellence into this beautiful song and once again treats us to the perfect glimpse of what indie music can be 😎

    Reply
  12. dom piper Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    dom piper

    Haha…. I think you referenced every single second as being wonderful Charles. If I hadn’t already heard it I would have taken it all with a little pinch of salt, but I already knew you were spot on in your analysis. This is a flawless piece of work. But then again, it’s Frank Joshua; so it’s kinda what we’ve come to expect. Brilliant Job Frank and thank you Charles for your expertly written corner of weekly joy. A true champion of the arts! 😎

    Reply
  13. Kris Townsent Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Kris Townsent

    Yes, it’s true that ballads aren’t heard that often these days. It’s a pity, really, because I used to enjoy listening to ballads a lot. I’ll listen to the song over the weekend when I have some peace and quiet. Thanks for the review and the song recommendation!

    Reply
  14. Marcus Magnusson Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Marcus Magnusson

    Regarding what’s in fashion at the moment, I think everything is in fashion at the same time these days. Everyone can tune in to what they like with the internet. The biggest pop stars before the internet was much more universally known than the current “pop-stars”. I bet everyone knew a few songs by Elvis, The Beatles and Michael Jackson in their day, but the majority of people now have probably not even heard of some of todays biggest names. And regarding Frank, it’s amazing how he can just continue to produce hit after hit for so long. Legend!

    Reply
  15. Djentleman Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Djentleman

    I, too, have lost my mother to Frank. Don’t worry. She’s still alive. But I told her the other day he has a new song out and it turns out she’d heard it before me. Some fan I am! Sorry Frank…

    Reply
  16. Chris Franklin Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Chris Franklin

    Hey Charles 😊. I love your thoughtful, psycho-babble opening, and I think you’re almost right, except I don’t think it’s just sadness per se, but rather music that moves us. It can be a happy love song, or even an instrumental piece; I find classical concerts can often move me to tears, and I even find “That’s The Way Of The World” by EWF brings a tear to my eye. However, it is not necessarily a sad feeling, but rather a kind of happy melancholy. Perhaps the Germans have a word for this feeling. As for Frank Joshua, I think he is one of the best artists in NAS. His writing and productions are always top-notch, and his vocals, well, you said it all. He also has a unique sound, which, in these days of cookie-cutter acts, is a rarity. This ballad is an absolute delight, beautifully performed and produced, as is all his work. I wish Frank every success ❤️ Show Less

    Reply
  17. Jane Marie Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Jane Marie

    YOU KNOW WHAT THAT VOICE LOOKS LIKE??!!! I am so jealous!!! 😂 Always have and always will be a huge fan of Frank!

    Reply
  18. Valeryan Richards Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Valeryan Richards

    I come from one of the generations that appreciates the sometimes deep sadness that a ballad can awaken in us ……Frank Joshua’s lyric and smooth voice along with the wonderful production certainly achieves this for me. Love your psychoanalyses … please keep them coming!

    Reply
  19. Steve Peacock Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    Steve Peacock

    I’m not usually a fan of ballads , but the review is encouraging me to go check out this week’s song. You’ve got to appreciate a good strong voice!

    Reply
  20. fabjani Avatar
    July 15, 2025
    fabjani

    Great analysis of a great song… And Charles, you’re right – what a wonderful, silky smooth voice.

    Reply
  21. Innovaniac Music Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Innovaniac Music

    Hmm, a creamy voice that all mothers love? As a dude, do I still check it out anyway? I’m guessing there’s something there for someone like me too.

    Reply
  22. crashworldband Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    crashworldband

    The first 10 seconds are truly sublime. Talk about setting the table. The voice is deep ‘n wide. It says, “there’s room for everyone in this voice…just listen”. Thought provoking lyrics. Yes, a true ballad. You’re right Charles, not heard so often these days. This is a gem of a song. The melody crests and falls like floating on a breeze. Great work Frank! And thank you Charles.

    Reply
  23. rikiabi34 Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    rikiabi34

    It is strange to hear facebook a d twitter in songs like this that remind me my childhood and the great piano-orchestral ballads of saturnday night entertainment tv-programs. Things of other times….like the chromatic harmonica mini-solos….omg is there people still playing it? Class really!! Crooner voice occupying all frequency range, with its calm is the loudest instrument in the mix! Remembers, nostalgia, a distant unended love…so much going on for your emotions! 🤟

    Reply
  24. Psychedelic Revolution Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Psychedelic Revolution

    “In the mainstream, they barely exist at the moment. They’re VERY out of fashion. In fact, I’m not really sure what IS in fashion.” I thought ‘No Time to Die’ by Billie Eilish was a ballad 🙂 Still in vogue mate 🙂

    Reply
  25. Dream Optimist Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Dream Optimist

    “All mothers love Frank Joshua” is a great takeaway here. Clear song, clear voice, clear vision – very cool song, great artist…

    Reply
  26. Delaye Julien Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Delaye Julien

    Ballads have always been present and important in rock music and Frank plays it great with this one once again !! Thank Charles for this article !

    Reply
  27. AgingTeenIdol Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    AgingTeenIdol

    “I learned to much or maybe wrong. The world don’t want a thinking song.” Seems like I hear a lot of ballads starting to surface. I think the song is brilliant and you were corrct in reviewing it. Well donr, once again, Charles.

    Reply
  28. Emily Gray Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Emily Gray

    I loooove a good ballad! Fantastic for Kareoke hahaha. Another wonderful track from Frank Joshua. That voice will always amaze me 😍

    Reply
  29. Vladislav Kubíček Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Vladislav Kubíček

    For some reason, while listening, I was reminded of the paintings of the Impressionists. Their capture of a moment, light, mood. A world created by small touches.

    Reply
  30. Jacob Tell Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Jacob Tell

    Thank you for the insightful analysis of Frank Joshua’s latest. I heard it for the first time last week on Mr. Oddzo’s Thursday show. I’ve been listening to it habitually ever since. An overwhelmingly heartbreaking work. Frank’s talents as a vocalist and masterful songwriter infuse every note of “Melanie Klein.” An instant classic.

    Reply
  31. Bob Kitt Avatar
    July 16, 2025
    Bob Kitt

    Another stellar review of a stellar song. Frank’s voice is a special thing indeed – not that his songwriting is a slouch. Emotive performances, atmospheric melodies and crystal clear production. This track has it all!

    Reply
  32. Terrestrial Animal Avatar
    July 17, 2025
    Terrestrial Animal

    Ballads have always had a special place in music, they definitely evoke “all the feels”, especially when you yourself are going through some rough emotions. Frank definitely nails it here as this is an emotionally charged song that people can easily connect with. As for the gravitational pull towards sad songs… I personally love sad songs and angry songs. They make me happy. Truly happy music usually bores me, not always, but most of the time. Sad and angry are the way to go. Not sure why that is because I’m not sad or angry, but sad and angry definitely please me, lol. Thanks for the great article as always CC! Cheers

    Reply
  33. Maira Aslan Avatar
    July 17, 2025
    Maira Aslan

    Charles, your corner always slices through the noise. This week you’ve carved out something truly haunting with “Melanie Klein” by Frank Joshua. I feel your words when you lament the demise of the classic ballad. And you nailed it: most indie ballads may be dull, yet here we are, gladly caught in the web of this one. Thanks for spotlighting (pun intended) this track. It’s less lullaby, more incantation. Can’t wait for your next dive into the indie stack of new releases.

    Reply
  34. Simone Vignini Avatar
    July 17, 2025
    Simone Vignini

    Great voice Joshua, luckily no “plasticity” in this song! Thanks Charles for the nice article!

    Reply
  35. ebolutionate Avatar
    July 17, 2025
    ebolutionate

    Ah yes a ballad. It’s great to hear the different inflections that comes subtly. Well worded review as usual.

    Reply
  36. crimson.disc Avatar
    July 17, 2025
    crimson.disc

    Part of the connection with ballads is often the immediacy of heartbreak itself. People with stable relationships are less likely to be enamoured (or to wallow) in words that haven’t applied to them for a while. Today’s cultural shift seems to be to shorter term liasons with less strings attached, and more frequent moving on. Maybe that’s part of why the ballad has been superseded by the feel good sex vibe selfish song. Move on and regret nothing. Dunno.

    Reply
  37. Bernice Marsala Avatar
    July 18, 2025
    Bernice Marsala

    I recently saw someone say this about an actor’s voice, and I think it applies perfectly to Frank Joshua, “he has a voice that you want to bottle up and pour over pancakes.” 😂 But truly, he’s one of my favorite male voices in NAS, and it’s wonderfully suited for ballads!👌🏻 I love ballads, as you know, and I have noticed as they’ve dwindled out of the popular mainstream over the years. BUT they are still very prevalent with mainstream rock! 😉 I think that’s because rock (despite its “hardness”) has always been a “feeling” genre. It’s essentially just heavy classical if you think about it.

    Reply
  38. Blister Soul Avatar
    July 18, 2025
    Blister Soul

    Connollys Corner drinking game – drink every time the word ballad is mentioned. In all seriousness, this is a great song, and such a good vocal performance. Congratulations Frank!

    Reply
  39. Martin Koppmnn Avatar
    July 18, 2025
    Martin Koppmnn

    What a wonderful ballad! Frank Joshua has such a deep and beautiful voice. The Piano and the other instruments, especially the harmonica, are well picked and sound beautiful…

    Reply
  40. Thesecond Avatar
    July 18, 2025
    Thesecond

    I love a good ballad, and since it’s Frank Joshua on this one, then it’s definitely a good one. Dope review CC

    Reply
  41. Nate Fin Avatar
    July 19, 2025
    Nate Fin

    Wow Amazing artistry

    Reply
  42. junehollandmusic Avatar
    July 19, 2025
    junehollandmusic

    What a beautiful song Frank! Love that harmonica too! Haha envisioning that club full of everyone crying and whaling to Adele now Charles 🤣

    Reply
  43. Chris Frake Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Chris Frake

    Chris Frake Jul 20, 2025 The piano intro makes this song my favorite at the moment, thank you sir CC for the beautiful review Like Reply 1 Like Giuseppe Maria Bità Jul 20, 2025 The piano intro is magnificent. Warm voice that evokes a dream. The accordion playing between the verses is beautiful. A perfect song for those who want to relax during aperitivo. Superlative song. Like Reply Charles Connolly Jul 22, 2025 Replying to Giuseppe Maria Bità Will you ever read one of these articles? Pleased you liked the song. You do always listen to the song. But actually, I did wonder if it was an accordion. I decided it was probably more like a harmonica in the end. Like Reply Emma Dupéré Jul 20, 2025 J’adore les balades et celle-ci avec le piano, l’harmonica et la belle voix de Franck est très belle. Une super critique de Charles pour cette chanson pleine d’émotion ! Like Reply 1 Like Canelo Kot Jul 20, 2025 A song with a very emotional interpretation and whose sounds and atmosphere initially transport you to your own experiences. It’s an excellent ballad to simply sit back and listen to and let yourself go. Like Reply 1 Like andelectro music Jul 20, 2025 Great to see a review of the brilliant Frank Joshua. Interesting to find out about Tony White because, as great as the voice is, the production and arrangements are also peerless. Like Reply 1 Like Charles Connolly Jul 22, 2025 Replying to andelectro music Tony white is a stunning producer and engineer. He deserves the recognition. Like Reply Christine Shafransky Jul 20, 2025 This song is an excellent modern day ballad and Joshua’s voice is certainly exquisite! I love the swell of instruments that surround him in it and his genuine emotion that you can feel when he sings as you have said. Thank you for bringing this song to my attention. It was thoroughly enjoyed! Like Reply 1 Like Pablo Bianchi Jul 20, 2025 Otra enorme reseña! Felicidades!! Like Reply Patrick Laurin Jul 20, 2025 I’ve always been more of a ballads kind of guy, even if I enjoy all kinds of genres. I love when something is truly beautiful, sad, musical. That’s where the strong and important emotions are. A great song can make you rethink some parts of life! Like Reply 1 Like Nate Fin Jul 19, 2025 Wow Amazing artistry Like Reply Kaminski Jul 19, 2025 With a song title like “Melanie Klein,” you got me right away. It shows guts, artistry and good taste. And here again, the man without a face, but with a golden voice does not disappoint. But what strikes me most of all is the songwriting. It feels like a formula that is already familiar, but with fantastic results. Frank Joshua proves that music can be that good. Consider me a fan. Thanks Charles for highlighting this greatness. Like Reply 1 Like unobliterated Jul 19, 2025 Interesting idea for a song. And absolutely beautifully done. Bravo Frank and congrats Charles on another great review Like Reply 1 Like junehollandmusic Jul 19, 2025 What a beautiful song Frank! Love that harmonica too! Haha envisioning that club full of everyone crying and whaling to Adele now Charles 🤣 Like Reply 1 Like Bernice Marsala Jul 18, 2025 I recently saw someone say this about an actor’s voice, and I think it applies perfectly to Frank Joshua, “he has a voice that you want to bottle up and pour over pancakes.” 😂 But truly, he’s one of my favorite male voices in NAS, and it’s wonderfully suited for ballads!👌🏻 I love ballads, as you know, and I have noticed as they’ve dwindled out of the popular mainstream over the years. BUT they are still very prevalent with mainstream rock! 😉 I think that’s because rock (despite its “hardness”) has always been a “feeling” genre. It’s essentially just heavy classical if you think about it. Like Reply 1 Like Charles Connolly Jul 22, 2025 Replying to Bernice Marsala Can you remember which actor they were talking about? Would be interested to know. A rock ballad is a different thing to a BALLAD ballad. Like Reply Bernice Marsala Jul 22, 2025 Replying to Charles Connolly Jeffrey Dean Morgan. You may not know him, but he’s primarily known for being John Winchester in Supernatural and Negan in The Walking Dead. Like Reply Blister Soul Jul 18, 2025 Connollys Corner drinking game – drink every time the word ballad is mentioned. In all seriousness, this is a great song, and such a good vocal performance. Congratulations Frank! Like Reply 1 Like Martin Koppmnn Jul 18, 2025 What a wonderful ballad! Frank Joshua has such a deep and beautiful voice. The Piano and the other instruments, especially the harmonica, are well picked and sound beautiful… Like Reply 1 Like Thesecond Jul 18, 2025 I love a good ballad, and since it’s Frank Joshua on this one, then it’s definitely a good one. Dope review CC Like Reply 1 Like Terrestrial Animal Jul 17, 2025 Ballads have always had a special place in music, they definitely evoke “all the feels”, especially when you yourself are going through some rough emotions. Frank definitely nails it here as this is an emotionally charged song that people can easily connect with. As for the gravitational pull towards sad songs… I personally love sad songs and angry songs. They make me happy. Truly happy music usually bores me, not always, but most of the time. Sad and angry are the way to go. Not sure why that is because I’m not sad or angry, but sad and angry definitely please me, lol. Thanks for the great article as always CC! Cheers Like Reply 1 Like Maira Aslan Jul 17, 2025 Charles, your corner always slices through the noise. This week you’ve carved out something truly haunting with “Melanie Klein” by Frank Joshua. I feel your words when you lament the demise of the classic ballad. And you nailed it: most indie ballads may be dull, yet here we are, gladly caught in the web of this one. Thanks for spotlighting (pun intended) this track. It’s less lullaby, more incantation. Can’t wait for your next dive into the indie stack of new releases. Like Reply 1 Like Simone Vignini Jul 17, 2025 Great voice Joshua, luckily no “plasticity” in this song! Thanks Charles for the nice article! Like Reply 1 Like ebolutionate Jul 17, 2025 Ah yes a ballad. It’s great to hear the different inflections that comes subtly. Well worded review as usual. Like Reply 1 Like Show more comments

    Reply
  44. Giuseppe Maria Bità Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Giuseppe Maria Bità

    The piano intro is magnificent. Warm voice that evokes a dream. The accordion playing between the verses is beautiful. A perfect song for those who want to relax during aperitivo. Superlative song.

    Reply
  45. Emma Dupéré Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Emma Dupéré

    J’adore les balades et celle-ci avec le piano, l’harmonica et la belle voix de Franck est très belle. Une super critique de Charles pour cette chanson pleine d’émotion !

    Reply
  46. Christine Shafransky Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Christine Shafransky

    This song is an excellent modern day ballad and Joshua’s voice is certainly exquisite! I love the swell of instruments that surround him in it and his genuine emotion that you can feel when he sings as you have said. Thank you for bringing this song to my attention. It was thoroughly enjoyed!

    Reply
  47. Pablo Bianchi Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Pablo Bianchi

    Otra enorme reseña! Felicidades!!

    Reply
  48. Patrick Laurin Avatar
    July 20, 2025
    Patrick Laurin

    I’ve always been more of a ballads kind of guy, even if I enjoy all kinds of genres. I love when something is truly beautiful, sad, musical. That’s where the strong and important emotions are. A great song can make you rethink some parts of life!

    Reply
  49. Charles Connolly Avatar
    July 22, 2025
    Charles Connolly

    Will you ever read one of these articles? Pleased you liked the song. You do always listen to the song. But actually, I did wonder if it was an accordion. I decided it was probably more like a harmonica in the end.

    Reply
  50. Bernice Marsala Avatar
    July 22, 2025
    Bernice Marsala

    Jeffrey Dean Morgan. You may not know him, but he’s primarily known for being John Winchester in Supernatural and Negan in The Walking Dead.

    Reply
  51. Jane Marie Avatar
    July 23, 2025
    Jane Marie

    😂

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Innovaniac Music Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts

  • Why I Love This NAS Song: “Cup of Coffee” by Crash World

    February 4, 2026
  • 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Fly 5Y.A. – The Blindfold Experience

    February 3, 2026
  • Why I Love This NAS Song: “The Glass Notebook” by David Von Beahm from the album “Taking Back Time”

    February 2, 2026
  • 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗻𝗼𝗹𝗹𝘆’𝘀 𝗖𝗼𝗿𝗻𝗲𝗿 – this week: Truth Hurts – Cerulean Chameleon, Julie Hicklin

    January 27, 2026
New Artist Spotlight

New Artist Spotlight

We claim no credit for any images, music and/or videos posted on this site unless otherwise noted. All audio and visual content is copyright to its respectful owners. We are also in no way responsible for, or have control of the content of any external web site links. Please support the artists by streaming/purchasing their music, and buying tickets to their shows.

  • Instagram
  • X
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
  • Discord
  • Reddit

©2026 New Artist Spotlight